The Digest.

Nancy Grace · Video summary

CHRISTA PIKE “MAD AS HELL:” DATE WITH “OLD SPARKY?”

Convicted killer Christa Pike was scheduled to be executed by lethal injection, but the process was botched, leaving her alive, angry, and potentially facing the electric chair.

CHRISTA PIKE “MAD AS HELL:” DATE WITH “OLD SPARKY?” Watch on YouTube ↗

Key takeaways

Chapters

The digest

Christa Pike, a name synonymous with unimaginable cruelty, recently made headlines not for her heinous crimes, but for a botched execution attempt that left her alive, angry, and her victim's family retraumatized. Pike, convicted of the torture and murder of teen Colleen Slemmer, was scheduled to die by lethal injection. However, what unfolded was a series of failures by the state of Tennessee, raising serious questions about their competency in carrying out capital punishment and the ethical implications for all involved.

The Horrific Crime of Christa Pike

To understand the outrage surrounding Pike's survival, one must recall the brutality of her crime. In 1995, Christa Pike, then 18, lured 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer to a remote area. There, with the help of two accomplices, she subjected Slemmer to hours of torture. Pentagrams were carved into Slemmer's skin, and she was beaten mercilessly. When Slemmer attempted to escape, Pike chased her with a meat cleaver, hacking her in the back. The torture culminated in Pike smashing Slemmer's head with a chunk of asphalt, shattering her skull. In a grotesque display of depravity, Pike then extracted a piece of Slemmer's skull and proudly displayed it to her friends the following day, even dancing a jig. This chilling account, partially recounted by Pike herself in an interview, paints a picture of a remorseless killer.

Keep reading in The Digest

The full 2-minute article, 2 more sections, and every new episode from Nancy Grace and the creators you follow.

  1. The Botched Execution: A Cascade of Failures
  2. Legal Ramifications and Public Outcry
Read the full digest — free

More from Nancy Grace

“LEGALLY BLONDE” STAR SELMA BLAIR FACING 7 YEARS BEHIND BARS, FOR KICKING, BITING, PUNCHING MELTDOWN

Selma Blair, the beloved "Legally Blonde" star, faces seven years in prison and hefty fines after a mid-air meltdown involving kicking, biting, and punching. Nancy Grace investigates whether her multiple sclerosis (MS) and its powerful medications played a role in the violent outburst.

October 14, 2026

NYT EXEC DEAD, AGING IN-LAWS TAKE TURNS SHOOTING BC "FORCED" SON TO WEAR DRESSES, RPT

A New York Times executive is dead after his aging in-laws allegedly took turns shooting him in broad daylight, reportedly because he encouraged his son to wear dresses. The case raises questions about domestic violence, self-defense, and potential hate crime motives.

October 12, 2026

HARROWING HAYDEN PANETTIERE DEATH SCENE, $500K DOLLAR RING MISSING

Nancy Grace investigates the mysterious death of actress Hayden Panettiere, focusing on inconsistent reports from her boyfriend and the disappearance of valuable items, including a $500,000 engagement ring.

October 9, 2026

CHRISTA PIKE SURVIVES EXECUTION, MURDERED GIRL "ERASED FROM NARRATIVE"

Convicted killer Christa Pike survived a botched execution, sparking outrage and renewed focus on the victim, Colleen Slimmer, who has been largely forgotten in the narrative.

October 6, 2026

AMERICAN IDOL STAR WAILS OVER WIFE'S "DEATH": BOMBSHELL SENTENCE

American Idol star Caleb Flynn has been sentenced to life in prison without parole for the murder of his wife, Ashley Flynn. The case, marked by his dramatic courtroom performance and incriminating texts, has drawn widespread attention.

October 5, 2026

PR EXEC-MOM ANTOINETTE VANISHES, LEAVES KEYS, CELL, DOG

PR executive and single mother Antwanet Forbes vanishes from her DC home, leaving behind her car, phone, keys, and beloved dog. The investigation uncovers a history of domestic violence and an ongoing custody battle with her ex-partner, Russell Ashford.

October 4, 2026

All Nancy Grace summaries →