MythBusters · Video summary
Should You Really Stand In A Doorway During An Earthquake? | MythBusters
The MythBusters investigate whether standing in a doorway is the safest place to be during an earthquake. They build a giant shake table and test the myth on different types of houses.
Watch on YouTube ↗Key takeaways
- 🚪The myth that doorways are the safest place during an earthquake likely originated from older, unreinforced masonry buildings where doorways were often the strongest structural element.01:04
- 🏛️The California Academy of Sciences has an earthquake shake table capable of simulating powerful historical earthquakes, which inspired the MythBusters to build their own.01:40
- 🛠️The MythBusters' custom-built shake table is an 11x13 foot steel frame, weighing 5,000 pounds, designed to simulate both horizontal (X and Y) and vertical (Z) earthquake motions.04:10
- 🧱In the test with the old-style, unreinforced masonry house, the doorway remained standing and protected the mannequin, while other parts of the house collapsed.17:10
- 🏡Modern wood-frame houses built to current seismic codes are significantly more resilient, with the entire structure designed to absorb earthquake energy, making the doorway no longer a uniquely safe spot.19:00
- 🤕In the modern house test, the mannequin under the table was safer than the one in the doorway, which was repeatedly struck by the swinging door.22:13
Chapters
- 0:00Introduction to the Earthquake Doorway Myth
- 0:59Planning the Experiment and Visiting the California Academy of Sciences
- 5:15Building the MythBusters' Giant Shake Table
- 20:00Testing the Myth on an Old-Style Masonry House
- 30:00Testing the Myth on a Modern Wood-Frame House
- 40:00Conclusion: Doorway Myth Busted (with a Caveat)
The digest
For decades, the advice on what to do during an earthquake has been a subject of debate. The common wisdom, especially in areas prone to seismic activity like California, often suggested seeking refuge in a doorway. However, modern seismic safety guidelines advocate for a different approach: "drop, cover, and hold on." The MythBusters team put this long-standing myth to the test, exploring whether a doorway truly offers the best protection during an earthquake.
The Origin of the Doorway Myth
The MythBusters began their investigation by acknowledging the prevailing belief that doorways are the safest place during an earthquake. This advice, deeply ingrained in the minds of many who grew up in earthquake-prone regions, likely originated from observations of older, unreinforced masonry buildings. In such structures, doorways, often reinforced with more robust framing, might have indeed been the strongest part of the house, offering a slim chance of survival amidst collapsing walls. However, as building codes and construction techniques evolved, the structural integrity of homes changed dramatically, raising questions about the continued relevance of this advice.
Keep reading in The Digest
The full 4-minute article, 4 more sections, and every new episode from MythBusters and the creators you follow.
- Building the Ultimate Shake Table
- Testing the Myth on an Old-Style Masonry House
- Re-evaluating the Myth with a Modern Wood-Frame House
- The Verdict: Myth Busted (with a Caveat)
More from MythBusters
Can Gummy Bears Actually Be Used As Rocket Fuel? | Mythbusters
Mythbusters tackles a fan-favorite myth: can gummy bears actually be used as rocket fuel? The team experiments with various gummy bear preparations to see if the sugary treats can propel a rocket.
MythBusters Tests Two Of The Most Explosive Myths In Their Final Season | Mythbusters
In their final season, the Mythbusters tackle two explosive myths: whether a cement truck can contain a dynamite blast in a mail truck, and if a hovercraft can safely traverse a minefield.
Can You Cook Shrimp By Firing Them Through a "Special" Gun? | Mythbusters
Mythbusters tackles two viral food fables: cooking shrimp by firing them through an air cannon and juicing fruit with explosives. They meticulously recreate the setups to determine if these bizarre culinary claims hold any truth.
Is The U-2 Spy Plane The Hardest Aircraft In The World To Land? | MythBusters
Mythbusters Adam Savage and Jamie Hyneman investigate the U-2 spy plane's legendary difficulty to land and the potential lethality of commercial drones.
MythBusters Test a Law That Half The Country Disagrees With | MythBusters
MythBusters Adam Savage and Jamie Hyneman tackle two common driving myths: whether hands-free phone use is as distracting as handheld, and if Hollywood-style reverse driving is possible in real life.
Could Walter White's Trunk Machine Gun Actually Work? | MythBusters
MythBusters tackles two explosive challenges: the literal meaning of "blowing it out of the water" with a ship and a depth charge, and the feasibility of Walter White's trunk-mounted machine gun from the Breaking Bad finale.