MythBusters · Video summary
Are Hand Dryers Really Cleaner Than Paper Towels? | MythBusters
MythBusters investigates the hygiene of public restrooms, testing whether hand dryers are less sanitary than paper towels and which toilet stall is the cleanest.
Watch on YouTube ↗Key takeaways
- 💨The myth suggests that hand dryers are less sanitary than paper towels because they purge fewer pathogens and can spread microbe-laden air.00:56
- 🧼Proper hand washing with soap and water eliminates virtually all bacteria, making the drying method irrelevant if hands are washed correctly.01:23
- 💧When only rinsing hands with water (without soap), a significant amount of bacteria remains, representing a worst-case scenario for testing drying methods.04:22
- 📉Paper towels reduced bacterial load by 71%, while air dryers only reduced it by 23%, indicating paper towels are far more effective at removing bacteria.12:38
- 🦠Air dryers spread more bacteria into the surrounding environment (41 colonies) compared to paper towels (3 colonies).12:54
- 🚪The myth proposes that the toilet stall closest to the door is the cleanest because people avoid it, assuming it's the most used and dirtiest, or seeking more privacy.15:33
Chapters
- 0:00Introduction to Toilet Myths
- 1:56Hand Washing Baseline Test
- 7:15Setting Up the Restroom Experiment
- 11:45Bacterial Application and Swabbing Protocol
- 20:23Results of Hand Dryer vs. Paper Towel Test
- 22:00Introduction to the Cleanest Stall Myth
- 23:37Setting Up the Stall Usage Experiment
- 35:12Results of the Cleanest Stall Test
The digest
Public restrooms are a necessary evil, often approached with a mix of caution and mild disgust. But beyond the obvious visual cues, what hidden truths lie within these communal spaces? MythBusters, ever curious about the unseen and the unverified, delved into two prevalent myths surrounding public restroom hygiene: the cleanliness of hand dryers versus paper towels, and the surprising theory about which toilet stall is the least used and therefore the cleanest.
The Hand Dryer vs. Paper Towel Showdown
The first myth tackled the seemingly modern and sanitary solution of electric hand dryers. Many believe these high-tech devices are a more hygienic alternative to traditional paper towels, but a counter-myth suggests they might actually be less sanitary. The theory is twofold: hand dryers supposedly purge fewer pathogens than paper towels, and they can also fan a fog of microbe-laden air, turning a simple hand-drying experience into a “contamination catastrophe.”
Before diving into the experiment, the team first had to establish a baseline for hand cleanliness. They identified three common hand-washing behaviors in public restrooms: pretending to wash hands (just running water), getting hands wet but using no soap, and properly washing hands with soap and water. To test the efficacy of each, Adam and Jamie washed their hands using these three methods, and then swabs were taken and cultured. The results were stark: washing hands with soap and water yielded no detectable bacteria, while simply rinsing with water or pretending to wash left significant bacterial loads. This crucial finding led to the decision to use the “water rinse only” method for the main experiment, as it represented a realistic worst-case scenario for bacterial spread, ensuring that any differences in drying methods would be clearly attributable to the dryers themselves, not the initial hand-washing effectiveness.
Keep reading in The Digest
The full 4-minute article, 4 more sections, and every new episode from MythBusters and the creators you follow.
- Building the Ultimate Restroom for Science
- The Verdict: Paper Towels Reign Supreme
- The Cleanest Stall: A Deep Dive into Restroom Psychology
- The Surprising Truth About Stall Usage and Cleanliness
More from MythBusters
Can Gummy Bears Actually Be Used As Rocket Fuel? | Mythbusters
Mythbusters tackles a fan-favorite myth: can gummy bears actually be used as rocket fuel? The team experiments with various gummy bear preparations to see if the sugary treats can propel a rocket.
MythBusters Tests Two Of The Most Explosive Myths In Their Final Season | Mythbusters
In their final season, the Mythbusters tackle two explosive myths: whether a cement truck can contain a dynamite blast in a mail truck, and if a hovercraft can safely traverse a minefield.
Can You Cook Shrimp By Firing Them Through a "Special" Gun? | Mythbusters
Mythbusters tackles two viral food fables: cooking shrimp by firing them through an air cannon and juicing fruit with explosives. They meticulously recreate the setups to determine if these bizarre culinary claims hold any truth.
Is The U-2 Spy Plane The Hardest Aircraft In The World To Land? | MythBusters
Mythbusters Adam Savage and Jamie Hyneman investigate the U-2 spy plane's legendary difficulty to land and the potential lethality of commercial drones.
MythBusters Test a Law That Half The Country Disagrees With | MythBusters
MythBusters Adam Savage and Jamie Hyneman tackle two common driving myths: whether hands-free phone use is as distracting as handheld, and if Hollywood-style reverse driving is possible in real life.
Could Walter White's Trunk Machine Gun Actually Work? | MythBusters
MythBusters tackles two explosive challenges: the literal meaning of "blowing it out of the water" with a ship and a depth charge, and the feasibility of Walter White's trunk-mounted machine gun from the Breaking Bad finale.