Good Mythical Morning · Video summary
What’s The Best Dr. Pepper Knockoff?
Rhett & Link from Good Mythical Morning embark on a quest to find the best Dr. Pepper knockoff, tasting a variety of generic sodas to see which one comes closest to the original's unique 23 flavors.
Watch on YouTube ↗Key takeaways
- 🧐Dr. Pepper's 23 flavors are a well-guarded secret, with fans speculating on a diverse list from amaretto to raspberry.01:31
- 📜Dr. Pepper holds the distinction of being the oldest major soda brand, established in Waco, Texas, in 1885.02:09
- 😂The initial tasting setup was a prank, with Link unknowingly drinking Dr. Pepper while Rhett tasted the knockoffs.07:24
- 🤢Zevia's Dr. Pepper knockoff, sweetened with Stevia, was strongly disliked for its artificial taste, described as "river water."11:10
- 🤡Dr. Faygo, known for its association with the Insane Clown Posse, emerged as a strong contender for the best Dr. Pepper knockoff.13:08
- 🤯Through repeated exposure to Dr. Pepper and its imitations, Link developed a surprising, albeit slight, acquired taste for the original soda.20:52
Chapters
- 0:00Introduction to the Dr. Pepper Divide
- 0:12Understanding Dr. Pepper's 23 Flavors
- 0:39Tasting Dr. Dynamite (Albertsons)
- 0:43Tasting Dr. K (Kroger)
- 0:58Tasting Dr. Nice (Walgreens)
- 1:19The Dr. Pepper Prank Reveal
- 2:00Tasting Dr. Thunder (Walmart)
- 3:00Tasting Dr. Shasta
- 3:20Tasting Zevia
- 3:40Tasting Poppi Doc Pop
- 4:00Tasting Dr. Faygo
- 4:50Tasting Dr. Sprecher
- 5:00Tasting Dr. Brown's
- 5:10Tasting Dr. Fiesta (Food City Stores)
- 5:30Tasting Dr. Chill (Georgia)
- 5:40Tasting Dr. Publix (Georgia)
- 5:50Tasting Dr. B (HEB Store)
- 6:00Tasting Dr. Blast (Brookshire Grocery Company)
- 6:10Tasting Dr. Wham (Alabama)
- 6:20Tasting Mr. Pig (Piggly Wiggly)
- 6:40Finalists & Verdict
The digest
Dr. Pepper, with its enigmatic blend of 23 flavors, holds a unique and often polarizing position in the world of soft drinks. While some, like Rhett, consider it "God's gift to soda," others, like Link, find it less appealing. This divide sets the stage for a grand experiment on Good Mythical Morning: to discover if any of the numerous generic Dr. Pepper knockoffs can truly capture the essence of the original, or perhaps even surpass it.
The Original and Its Mystique
Before diving into the world of imitations, it's crucial to establish a baseline with the real Dr. Pepper. Originating in Waco, Texas, in 1885, it boasts the title of the oldest major soda brand. The exact 23 flavors remain a closely guarded secret, but mega-fans have speculated on a diverse list including amaretto, almond, blackberry, black licorice, caramel, carrot, cloves, cherry, cola, ginger, juniper, lemon, molasses, nutmeg, orange, prune, plum, pepper, root beer, rum, and raspberry. The 23rd, as Link humorously suggests, might just be "love" or "lack of taste." This complex flavor profile is what makes Dr. Pepper so distinctive and, consequently, so challenging to replicate.
Keep reading in The Digest
The full 4-minute article, 4 more sections, and every new episode from Good Mythical Morning and the creators you follow.
- The Early Contenders: Dr. K, Dr. Dynamite, and Dr. Nice
- The Mid-Tier: Dr. Thunder, Dr. Shasta, Zevia, and Poppi
- The Finalists Emerge: Dr. Faygo, Dr. Sprecher, Dr. Brown's, Dr. Fiesta, Dr. Chill, Dr. Publix, Dr. B, Dr. Blast, Dr. Wham, and Mr. Pig
- The Verdict: Crowning the Best Knockoff
More from Good Mythical Morning
Testing The World’s Most Comfortable Products
Rhett & Link test the world's coziest products, from beanbag chairs and cashmere socks to heated neck pillows and hot chocolate, to determine which items truly deliver on comfort.
We Try Science Experiments Without Instructions
Rhett and Link from Good Mythical Morning try to complete science experiments without instructions, leading to hilarious attempts and surprising scientific revelations.
Are You Smarter Than Rhett & Link?
Rhett & Link challenge their multi-generational employees to a trivia night to see which generation reigns supreme in a battle of wits.
Can We Find The Hidden Fast Food?
Rhett and Link from Good Mythical Morning challenge themselves to identify hidden fast food items disguised in elaborate dishes like pizza, Swedish meatballs, clam chowder, and cheesecake.
Mystery Ingredients Sandwich Battle
Rhett and Link go head-to-head in a series of mystery ingredient battles, drafting unexpected combinations to create new recipes and avoid culinary chaos.
Mystery Ingredients Sandwich Battle
Rhett and Link go head-to-head in a series of mystery ingredient battles, drafting ingredients to create new and unexpected recipes. They compete to build the best breakfast bowl, rough night sandwich, and soft-serve dessert, with hilarious and often chaotic results.