This American Life · Podcast summary
646: The Secret of My Death
A man who went to a stranger’s funeral and had to piece together all the stuff he would want to know in that kind of situation.
Listen on the show ↗Key takeaways
- ✉️Charlie's friend Mark asked him to attend a Navy SEAL's funeral in San Diego on his behalf, as Mark couldn't make it from Florida.00:48
- 🤔Charlie initially considered making an excuse not to go, as attending a stranger's funeral felt rude and inappropriate.01:03
- 📰Charlie discovered through a Facebook memorial and GoFundMe page that Eddie Forlani, the SEAL, had passed away suddenly, but there was no official reporting on the cause of death.01:58
- 😭During the funeral, Charlie witnessed Eddie's seven-year-old daughter, Zelma, break down in tears, which made the stoic Navy SEALs around him appear helpless.05:20
- 🧠Charlie realized that Zelma, despite being young, understood the gravity of her father's death, unlike the military training that teaches emotional suppression.06:34
- 💡Charlie learned that Eddie Forlani had committed suicide, a detail intentionally omitted from the service and news, causing Charlie to feel lightheaded and physically affected.09:44
Chapters
- 0:00Prologue
- 0:42Act One: Funeral For A Stranger
- 7:07Act Two: The Secret Of My Death
- 11:17Act Three: This Is Your Afterlife
The digest
Charlie, a retired officer in the Navy, wrote an essay about a guy who helped him, a Marine who died in Iraq, Major Richard Gannon, the Second. Charlie went to a stranger’s funeral and had to piece together all the stuff he would want to know in that kind of situation. This is his story.
The Random Text Message
Charlie and his friend Mark went to the Naval Academy together. After graduation, Charlie went on to become a Naval aviator. He flew medevac helicopters in Iraq in 2007. His friend Mark joined the Navy SEALs, the Navy special operations forces. What was the text that you got from Mark?
Charlie says, "Hey, I got a job for you." And Charlie's response came back, "Does it involve explosives?" Charlie says, "Uh, and he says, attend the service of a frogman in my absence." Frogman is a nickname for a Navy SEAL. The funeral was going to be in San Diego, and Mark, who lives in Florida, couldn't make it. So he asked Charlie, who lives nearby, to go in his place. Charlie says, "That was the moment where it was like that moment of decision where it's like, well, do I really want to go to a funeral of somebody I don't know in his absence?" Charlie says, "If it was anybody but Mark, I probably would have, would have made an excuse." So did you sit there for like a minute or two before you wrote him back, thinking of excuses not to go?
Charlie says, "I'd be lying if I said no. I I I did think of a few excuses not to go because, you know, funerals aren't one of those things that people like attending to begin with, and let alone the funeral of somebody that you don't know, which technically seems a little rude because just doesn't seem appropriate." But Charlie wrote Mark back, said, "Send me the details and I'll do it." And then, in the swirl of his own life and work and family, he kind of forgot about it.
Keep reading in The Digest
The full 12-minute article, 4 more sections, and every new episode from This American Life and the creators you follow.
- The Morning of the Funeral
- The Funeral Service
- The Aftermath
- The Essay
More from This American Life
898: An Argument
Nicole Hannah-Jones reflects on her decade-old decision to enroll her daughter in a segregated public school, exploring the complex realities of educational inequality and integration.
897: Intergenerational Space Travel
Producer Josh Reddick's new walk-up song has become a huge part of Major League Baseball.
896: I Know What You Need
School nurse Meredith Manwaring and her district's superintendent and health department fought a measles outbreak and won. They share how they did it, and what they learned.
206: Somewhere in the Arabian Sea
Life on an aircraft carrier in the Arabian Sea, where thousands of young people are cooped up together for months at a time, far from home, and trying to keep people from having sex with each other.
895: Label Maker!
Comedian Janet McNamara and others discuss the labels we apply to ourselves and others, and the surprising power these labels can hold.